On Simplicity
Simple can be harder than complex: You have to work hard to get your thinking clean to make it simple. Steve Jobs
Some of the latest developments surrounding the adoption of artificial intelligence concern me:
Even before the advent of generative AI, humanity was consuming natural resources at a rate exceeding far what our planet can sustainably regenerate. The rapid expansion of computing capacity around the world places an additional burden on an already strained environment. Building and operating data centres requires substantial amounts of raw materials, electricity and water — valuable resources that are also needed to satisfy more essential human needs.
With this essay, I want to take a critical stance on this development and illustrate how the guiding principle of simplicity can serve as a guardrail for a more responsible and well-tempered use of artificial intelligence.
What is simple?
Simple is a universal quality of being. A particular thing is simple when it fulfils its purpose with the minimum necessary complexity over its entire life cycle.
A thing is simple when it is reduced to its conceptual essence. I like my writings to be simple: Crafted in such a way that nothing can be removed without diminishing their meaning. Attentive followers of the On-Series will realise how much can be expressed with few words once a set of carefully constructed concepts has been established as foundation.
A thing is simple if it is effective, efficient and elegant. Last month a dog called Jessie of a good friend of mine passed away - being of the Greyhound breed his graceful gait will be forever in my mind as a natural expression of those simple attributes.
What is simplicity?
Simplicity is the guiding principle of preferring simple things over comparable but more complicated alternatives. This principle can be applied across domains:
Simplicity as scientific principle
Also known as Occam's razor, this principle favours scientific theories that rely on fewer assumptions, provided they explain the empirical evidence equally well.
Simplicity as a mathematical principle
Pure mathematics provides a precise symbolic language for representing universal entities and their timeless relations. A central idea in mathematics is the identification of a minimal basis, i.e. a collection of independent, composable primitives that provide maximum expressive power.
Simplicity as a principle of life organisation
Simplicity favours stable relationships, clear responsibilities and mutual support. The traditional family exemplifies this well by fostering cooperation across generations, with the elderly contributing to the upbringing of children while receiving care and companionship in return.
It appears that simplicity requires selectivity, i.e the deliberate choice of one out of many alternatives, through an interplay of experimentation, reflection and reasoning.
Generative AI vs. Simplicity
AI makes it considerably easier to generate digital content in various forms from instructions expressed in natural language. I still find it fascinating how well large language models perform the role of a kind of universal interpreter, capable of translating our intentions into a wide range of specialised formal languages and other forms of digital media.
However, we should not overlook that there is a conceptually simpler way to communicate, i.e. a direct communication without an intermediary. Rather than delegating every act of expression to a universal, computation-intensive model, we can develop and sharpen our own expressive capabilities by mastering the specialised, artistic languages ourselves.
Generative AI presents a great educational opportunity in this pursuit, serving as a patient and knowledgeable teacher, provided we remain aware of its underlying mechanics and limitations. After all, even the most capable interpreter may struggle to faithfully convey every nuance of our stated intentions.
We should therefore remain curious, critical and open-minded about the tools and conventions we employ, continually questioning and refining them. Cultivating our individual and collective expressive capabilities requires not only exploring new possibilities, but also the selectivity to identify and agree upon the most essential ones. Guided by the principle of simplicity, we should favour quality over quantity and strive to express more with less.